Home > News & Blogs > 2018 Subcompact SUV Challenge: Which Small SUV Reigns Supreme?

2018 Subcompact SUV Challenge: Which Small SUV Reigns Supreme?

2018 Subcompact SUV Challenge: Which Small SUV Reigns Supreme? | MotorVero

2018 Subcompact SUV Showdown: Finding the Best Small SUV Under $26,000

best subcompact SUV 2018

The subcompact SUV segment has exploded with options since our last comparison. We put four top contenders through rigorous testing to determine which delivers the best combination of value, comfort and capability.

Test Methodology: How We Evaluated

Our comprehensive evaluation process included:

  • Price Limit: $26,000 including destination
  • Transmission: Automatic required
  • Drive Type: AWD availability required (tested as equipped)
  • Test Vehicles:
    • Ford EcoSport SE FWD
    • Hyundai Kona SEL AWD
    • Nissan Rogue Sport SV FWD
    • Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Premium AWD

Three expert judges evaluated each vehicle across 13 categories using a 1,000-point scoring system:

Kelsey Mays
Senior Consumer Affairs Editor
15 years automotive testing experience
Fred Meier
Washington, D.C. Bureau Chief
Former USA Today auto editor
Brian Wong
Los Angeles Bureau Chief
Specializes in urban vehicle testing

1. 2018 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Premium AWD - 852/1000

The redesigned Crosstrek defended its title with improved refinement, class-leading safety tech, and legendary Subaru capability.

Strengths

  • Best standard AWD system in class
  • 8.7 inches of ground clearance
  • EyeSight safety suite availability
  • Spacious interior for class
  • Smooth ride quality

Weaknesses

  • Underpowered 152-hp engine
  • Basic interior materials
  • Noisy at highway speeds
Price as Tested: $25,920
Engine: 2.0L H4
MPG: 27 city/33 hwy
Cargo Space: 20.8 cu.ft
Car Seat Check: B+
Safety Tech: Standard

2. 2018 Hyundai Kona SEL AWD - 814/1000

Strengths

  • Peppy 1.6L turbo option
  • User-friendly tech interface
  • Fun-to-drive character
  • Excellent warranty coverage

Weaknesses

  • Cramped rear seat
  • Firm ride quality
  • Polarizing styling
Price as Tested: $24,950
Engine: 2.0L I4
MPG: 26 city/29 hwy
Cargo Space: 19.2 cu.ft
Car Seat Check: B
Safety Tech: Available

3. 2018.5 Nissan Rogue Sport SV FWD - 642/1000

Strengths

  • Standard safety features
  • Comfortable front seats
  • Familiar Rogue styling

Weaknesses

  • Underwhelming acceleration
  • Cheap interior plastics
  • No AWD in our test
Price as Tested: $25,400
Engine: 2.0L I4
MPG: 25 city/32 hwy
Cargo Space: 22.9 cu.ft
Car Seat Check: B-
Safety Tech: Standard

4. 2018 Ford EcoSport SE FWD - 498/1000

Strengths

  • SYNC 3 infotainment system
  • Tall seating position
  • Available turbo engine

Weaknesses

  • Dated platform design
  • Poor rear visibility
  • Awkward side-swing tailgate
Price as Tested: $23,995
Engine: 2.0L I4
MPG: 23 city/29 hwy
Cargo Space: 20.9 cu.ft
Car Seat Check: C+
Safety Tech: Limited


Key Takeaways for Buyers

Our testing revealed several important segment trends:

  • Capability vs Efficiency: The Crosstrek proves you don't have to choose
  • Safety Matters: Standard driver aids becoming expected
  • Space Utilization: Clever packaging separates leaders from laggers
  • Tech Expectations: Even budget SUVs need modern interfaces

The subcompact SUV market continues to evolve rapidly, with new entrants like the Toyota CH-R and Volkswagen T-Roc poised to challenge these results in future comparisons.

proImg

Klash

Last Updated On Oct, 07-2025

Share Now: