2018 Subcompact SUV Showdown: Finding the Best Compact Crossover

The subcompact SUV segment exploded in popularity throughout the 2010s, and by 2018, buyers faced more quality options than ever. MotorVero conducted an exhaustive comparison test of four leading contenders: the all-new Hyundai Kona, the revised Subaru Crosstrek, Nissan's Rogue Sport, and Ford's American debut of the EcoSport. Our testing revealed clear winners and losers in this competitive class.

--FIRST CAR LIST HERE--

Testing Methodology: How We Determined the Best

To ensure fair comparisons, we established strict testing parameters:

• Price cap: $26,000 including destination charges
• Transmission: Automatic required
• Drivetrain: AWD availability required (though test vehicles could be FWD)
• Model years: All 2018 models except the 2018.5 Nissan Rogue Sport

Our expert evaluation team assessed each vehicle across 13 critical categories, from interior quality to driving dynamics. We supplemented subjective judgments with objective measurements of cargo capacity, safety tech assessments, and child seat compatibility tests.

--TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

The Contenders: 2018's Top Subcompact SUVs

4th Place: 2018 Ford EcoSport SE FWD (498/1000 points)

The EcoSport's global roots showed through in its compromised packaging. While it offered excellent tech features, the powertrain and interior space couldn't compete with newer designs. The side-hinged rear door proved particularly problematic in urban environments.

--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

3rd Place: 2018 Hyundai Kona SEL AWD (525/1000 points)

The Kona represented Hyundai's first serious entry into the subcompact SUV segment. While it excelled in driving dynamics and value, some cost-cutting in materials and its small size relative to competitors held it back from the top spots.

The Top Performers

2nd Place: 2018 Nissan Rogue Sport SV FWD (636/1000 points)

The Rogue Sport (sold as the Qashqai in global markets) impressed with its:

• Class-leading cargo capacity
• Comfortable, supportive seats
• Standard advanced safety features
• Excellent outward visibility

Where it fell short:

• Uninspiring driving dynamics
• CVT transmission dulls responsiveness
• Some cheap interior plastics
• --FORTH CAR LIST HERE--
  
• 
  

1st Place: 2018 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Premium AWD (661/1000 points)

The redesigned Crosstrek maintained its position as class leader by excelling in:

• Best-in-class ride and handling balance
• Spacious interior with adult-friendly rear seats
• Standard AWD with excellent fuel economy
• Superior outward visibility
• Excellent safety ratings and available features
• --THIRD CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
  

Minor drawbacks included:

• Modest acceleration
• Some road noise at highway speeds
• Basic infotainment system

Key Decision Factors for Subcompact SUV Buyers

When shopping this segment, consider these critical factors:

Space vs. Maneuverability

The Crosstrek and Rogue Sport offered more passenger and cargo room, while the Kona and EcoSport were easier to park in tight urban spaces.

Drivetrain Preferences

Only the Crosstrek included standard AWD, while others offered it as an option. The Kona's conventional automatic appealed to drivers who dislike CVTs.

--BOTTOM ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Technology Needs

The EcoSport's Sync 3 system led the pack, while Subaru's Starlink system trailed in responsiveness and features.

--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--

Safety Considerations

The Rogue Sport included standard automatic emergency braking, while the EcoSport lacked even availability of this important safety tech.

2018 vs. Today: How These Models Have Evolved

Since our 2018 test, all four models have received updates:

• Crosstrek: Gained a more powerful optional engine and improved tech
• Kona: Received a complete redesign with more interior space
• Rogue Sport: Discontinued after 2022 model year
• EcoSport: Discontinued after 2022 without a direct replacement

While newer models offer improved technology and efficiency, our 2018 findings remain relevant for used car shoppers evaluating these vehicles in today's market.

--SIXTH CAR LIST HERE--