Shocking Crash Test Results: Safety Doesn't Always Match Price
Recent independent testing conducted for Consumer Reports evaluated 34 rear-facing infant car seats in rigorous crash simulations. The results surprised many parents and safety experts:
--FIRST CAR LIST HERE--
- Only 13 seats earned the highest "Best" rating
- 16 models received mid-level "Better" scores
- 5 car seats performed at the "Basic" level
Key Finding:
Price showed little correlation with safety performance. The $55 Evenflo Discovery 5 outperformed the $440 Orbit Baby G2, which received only a Basic rating.
Understanding the Safety Ratings
Consumer Reports updated their testing protocol to better simulate real-world conditions:
- Increased simulated crash speed from 30mph to 35mph
- Used actual vehicle seating hardware from a 2010-11 Ford Flex
- Added simulated front seatback interaction
- Measured head injury risk and structural integrity
These tests evaluate protection beyond federal minimum standards, providing parents with an extra margin of safety information.
--TOP ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Rating System Explained
| Rating |
Meaning |
Safety Margin |
| Best |
Superior crash protection |
Exceeds standards by 30%+ |
| Better |
Good crash protection |
Exceeds standards by 15-29% |
| Basic |
Meets minimum standards |
0-14% above requirements |
Top-Performing Infant Car Seats (Best Rating)
These 13 models demonstrated exceptional safety performance in crash testing:
- Britax B-Safe
- Chicco KeyFit & KeyFit 30
- Cybex Aton 2
- Cosco Comfy Carry
- Evenflo Secure Ride 35
- Graco SnugRide 30 (Classic Connect)
- Maxi-Cosi Mico
- Safety 1st Comfy Carry Elite/Elite Plus
- Safety 1st onBoard35 Air
- The First Years Contigo & Via I470
Notably, this list includes seats across various price points, proving safety doesn't require premium spending.
--SECOND CAR LIST HERE--
Basic-Rated Seats: What Parents Should Know
Five seats received Basic ratings due to specific performance issues:
- Evenflo Embrace 35 (Select) - Detached from base
- Graco SnugRide (Classic Connect) - Base cracking
- Maxi-Cosi Prezi - Elevated head injury risk
- Orbit Baby G2 - High head injury risk
- Snugli Infant Car Seat - Detached from base
Expert Insight:
"Basic doesn't mean unsafe - these seats still meet all federal requirements. However, parents might prefer seats that exceed minimum standards," explains child safety technician Maria Weston.
Beyond Crash Tests: 5 Essential Buying Factors
While crash performance is crucial, consider these additional elements when choosing a car seat:
- Proper Fit: Ensure the seat fits your child's current height/weight
- Vehicle Compatibility: Test installation in your car before purchasing
- Ease of Use: Complicated installations increase misuse risk
- Growth Accommodation: Some seats accommodate infants longer
- Additional Features: Consider canopy coverage, carrying handles, and padding
Federal Standards vs. Independent Testing
All car seats sold in the U.S. must meet Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard 213, which requires:
- Simulated 30mph frontal crash survival
- Head injury criteria below 1,000 HIC
- Chest deceleration below 60g
- No complete separation of components
Consumer Reports' more rigorous testing helps identify seats that provide additional protection beyond these minimums.
--FIRST CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT HERE--
Installation: The Hidden Safety Factor
Proper installation is equally important as seat selection. Studies show:
- 59% of car seats have installation errors
- Proper use reduces injury risk by 71%
- Common mistakes include loose straps and incorrect recline angles
Always consult both your vehicle manual and car seat instructions, or visit a certified Child Passenger Safety Technician.
Get Installation Help →
